• Breaking News
  • U.S. News
  • Contact
  • View Print Edition
    • CL Digital
  • Subscribe
Friday, August 19, 2022
  • Login
No Result
View All Result
Advertise with us
The Chicago Leader
Donate Now
  • Home
    • Subscribe to the print newspaper
    • Scavenger Hunt Contest
    • Download Media Kit PDF
    • Ad submission
    • Sponsors
  • World
    Cancer

    Scientists Make Breakthrough That Could Eliminate Cancer Cells

    Monkeys

    Monkeys Attack Children and Elderly in Yamaguchi

    Polar bear

    Polar Bear Subpopulation Found in Southeast Greenland

    Trending Tags

    • Breaking News
    • Health
    • Coronavirus
    • coronavirus pandemic
  • U.S. News
    • All
    • Black History
    • Chicago
    • Illinois
    Public Transportation

    Why Is Public Transportation Unsafe?

    988

    New 988 Hotline Launches in Illinois

    Illinois

    Illinois Residents Will Soon See Checks in the Mail

    Trending Tags

    • U.S.
    • U.S. Census
    • Politics
  • Business
    • All
    • Jobs
    Equifax

    Equifax Causes Woman to Make Two Car Payments Due to Credit Error

    Joe Biden’s Economy is Booming and the Right Wing Is Speechless

    Joe Biden’s Economy is Booming and the Right Wing Is Speechless

    Save A Lot

    Save A Lot Granted $13.5M for Stores in Chicago

    Trending Tags

    • Wall Street
    • Trump
    • Bankruptcy
    • Federal Reserve Bank
  • Technology
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Arts
    • Book Review
    • Chicago Film Office
    • Gaming
    • Movie
    • Music
    • Review
    streaming

    Streaming Platforms Leave Broadcast and Cable TV in the Dust

    Chicago

    Classic Chicago Film Locations

    Rowling

    Threat Made Against J.K. Rowling After Salman Rushdie Was Attacked

    Trending Tags

    • Movies
    • marvel movies
    • Dancing
  • Sports
  • Science
    • All
    • CBD
    • Climate
    • Marijuana
    carbon

    Carbon Emissions Alter Earth’s Ability to Heal Itself

    pig

    Scientists Restore Pig Organs After Their Heart Stop

    face mask

    New Face Mask Material Can Deactivate COVID-19 Particles

    Trending Tags

    • UFO
    • Coronavirus
    • Novel coronavirus
    • coronavirus pandemic
    • NASA
    • scientists
  • Health
    • All
    • COVID-19
    • Faith
    • food
    • homeopathy
    • mental health
    • prostate
    greyhound

    Greyhound Tests Positive for Monkeypox in France

    Vitamin

    Vitamin B12 Could Help People With Nonalcoholic Fatty Liver Disease

    Virus

    Scientists Identify 35 Cases of New Spillover Virus in China

    Trending Tags

    • Golden Globes
    • Mr. Robot
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Climate Change
    • Flat Earth
  • English
  • Spanish
  • Home
    • Subscribe to the print newspaper
    • Scavenger Hunt Contest
    • Download Media Kit PDF
    • Ad submission
    • Sponsors
  • World
    Cancer

    Scientists Make Breakthrough That Could Eliminate Cancer Cells

    Monkeys

    Monkeys Attack Children and Elderly in Yamaguchi

    Polar bear

    Polar Bear Subpopulation Found in Southeast Greenland

    Trending Tags

    • Breaking News
    • Health
    • Coronavirus
    • coronavirus pandemic
  • U.S. News
    • All
    • Black History
    • Chicago
    • Illinois
    Public Transportation

    Why Is Public Transportation Unsafe?

    988

    New 988 Hotline Launches in Illinois

    Illinois

    Illinois Residents Will Soon See Checks in the Mail

    Trending Tags

    • U.S.
    • U.S. Census
    • Politics
  • Business
    • All
    • Jobs
    Equifax

    Equifax Causes Woman to Make Two Car Payments Due to Credit Error

    Joe Biden’s Economy is Booming and the Right Wing Is Speechless

    Joe Biden’s Economy is Booming and the Right Wing Is Speechless

    Save A Lot

    Save A Lot Granted $13.5M for Stores in Chicago

    Trending Tags

    • Wall Street
    • Trump
    • Bankruptcy
    • Federal Reserve Bank
  • Technology
  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Arts
    • Book Review
    • Chicago Film Office
    • Gaming
    • Movie
    • Music
    • Review
    streaming

    Streaming Platforms Leave Broadcast and Cable TV in the Dust

    Chicago

    Classic Chicago Film Locations

    Rowling

    Threat Made Against J.K. Rowling After Salman Rushdie Was Attacked

    Trending Tags

    • Movies
    • marvel movies
    • Dancing
  • Sports
  • Science
    • All
    • CBD
    • Climate
    • Marijuana
    carbon

    Carbon Emissions Alter Earth’s Ability to Heal Itself

    pig

    Scientists Restore Pig Organs After Their Heart Stop

    face mask

    New Face Mask Material Can Deactivate COVID-19 Particles

    Trending Tags

    • UFO
    • Coronavirus
    • Novel coronavirus
    • coronavirus pandemic
    • NASA
    • scientists
  • Health
    • All
    • COVID-19
    • Faith
    • food
    • homeopathy
    • mental health
    • prostate
    greyhound

    Greyhound Tests Positive for Monkeypox in France

    Vitamin

    Vitamin B12 Could Help People With Nonalcoholic Fatty Liver Disease

    Virus

    Scientists Identify 35 Cases of New Spillover Virus in China

    Trending Tags

    • Golden Globes
    • Mr. Robot
    • MotoGP 2017
    • Climate Change
    • Flat Earth
  • English
  • Spanish
No Result
View All Result
Chicago Leader
No Result
View All Result

Setting Term Limits for Supreme Court Justices Is a Logical Beginning

by Cathy Milne-Ware
July 3, 2022
in Featured, Headlines, Politics, U.S. News
0
Term Limits

Courtesy of risingthermals (Flickr CC0)

0
SHARES
10
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
Don't like to read?

After recent controversial decisions by the Supreme Court on abortion, the 2nd Amendment, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), religious freedom, and Indigenous tribal affairs, the discussion of establishing term limits and impeachment has significantly increased in the news and on social media. Since a series of impeachments are unlikely, term limits are a logical beginning.

Ending lifetime appointments should not be a conservative vs. liberal discussion; historically, it has not.

During his bid for U.S. President in June 2015, former Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee posted a pledge on Facebook, “I will fight for term limits for members of Congress and judges.” Earlier that year, he told reporters:

Nobody should be in an unelected position for life. … If the president who appoints them can only serve eight years, the person they appoint should never serve 40. That has never made sense to me; it defies that sense of public service.

President Joe Biden empaneled a commission on April 9, 2021, after Democrats demanded: “What they called the ideological balance on the court,” according to The Washington Post. The bipartisan Presidential Commission on the Supreme Court of the United States voted unanimously to submit its 294-page report on its findings.

Term Limits
Courtesy of Gage Skidmore (Flickr CC0)

It is not easy to know what the president will do since during his campaign said he was against term limits for the Supreme Court. “It’s a lifetime appointment. I’m not going to attempt to change that at all.”

Rep. Ro Khanna (D-Calif.) posted a series of tweets on June 24, 2022, after Roe v. Wade was overturned. Congress must address “the politicization of the Supreme Court that paved the way for this decision. It is time to end lifetime appointments to the Supreme Court to restore judicial independence and trust in the highest court in the land.”

He tweeted it was time for Congress to pass and the president to sign his bill to set 18-year term limits. Democrat Reps. Khanna (CA-17), Don Beyer (VA-08), Barbara Lee (CA-14), and Rashida Talib (MI-13) reintroduced the Supreme Court Term Limits Act, which was initially introduced last legislative session.

NEW PUBLIC OPINION POLL:
Nearly 7 in 10 Americans support setting term limits on Supreme Court justices after string of incendiary, unpopular rulings on abortion, guns, church and state, and Miranda rights. pic.twitter.com/RKCqmAUxXT

— Deb VanderGaast for Iowa Senate (@DebCares4Iowa) July 2, 2022

Why do Supreme Court Justices have life-long appointments or life tenure? Scholars claim the Founding Fathers established this rule in the United States Constitution; Article III, Section 1: “The Judges, both of the supreme and inferior Courts, shall hold their Offices during good Behaviour…” But, who determines the meaning of “good behavior” and enforces those rules?

Term Limits
Courtesy of The Wolf Law Library (Flickr CC0)

The Federalist, a collection of 85 essays written to help Americans better understand the U.S. Constitution, offers some clarification. In “Federalist Essay No. 78,” Alexander Hamilton wrote the judiciary (courts and judges) must be independent of the government’s legislative (politicians and lawmakers) branch. He claimed that life tenures freed judges from political pressure that might happen if they must be re-appointed or re-elected. Freeing justices from this pressure enables them to guard against laws contrary to the Constitution, according to APGoPo, an Advanced Placement United States Government and Politics college-level course.

Hamilton added that because being a judge places great demands on a person and few “men” have the requirements and ethical qualities, life-long appointments are necessary. He asserted periodic appointments would discourage qualified from seeking the position. He thought this would lead to a judiciary filled with less competent and principled judges.

One of those principles Hamilton refers to is understanding that laws cannot conflict with the will of the people — the U.S. Constitution — as opposed to those passed by elected representatives. The justices’ job is to interpret if a law violates that principle, according to APGoPo.

Thomas Jefferson and other Founding Fathers argued against lifetime appointments of SCOTUS Justices.

British columnist wrote this prophetic line: “The Supreme Court has now set the nation on a path that will be politically and socially disastrous.” He is correct.

Written by Cathy Milne-Ware

Sources:

The Washington Post: Mike Huckabee suggested term limits for the Supreme Court today. That’s not such a good idea. By Janell Ross
The Washington Post: Biden’s Thorny Options for Changing the Supreme Court; by Kimberly Robinson and Madison Alder
AXIOS: First Look: Ro Khanna to push Biden to back SCOTUS term limits; Sophia Cal
The White House: Presidential Commission on the Supreme Court of the United States
Congressman Ro Khanna: RELEASE: REPS. KHANNA, BEYER, LEE, TLAIB INTRODUCE LEGISLATION TO SET SUPREME COURT TERM LIMITS, APPOINTMENTS SCHEDULE, WITHOUT CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT
Congressional Research Service: A Code of Conduct for the Supreme Court? Legal Questions and Considerations; LSB10255.pdf

Featured and Top Image Courtesy of risingthermals’ Flickr Page – Creative Commons License
First Inset Image Courtesy of Gage Skidmore’s Flickr Page – Creative Commons License
Second Inset Image Courtesy of The Wolf Law Library’s Flickr Page – Creative Commons License

Tags: term limits
Cathy Milne-Ware

Cathy Milne-Ware

Next Post
Sharks

“Take That, Mr. Shark!”

Recent Posts

  • Streaming Platforms Leave Broadcast and Cable TV in the Dust
  • Why Is Public Transportation Unsafe?
  • New 988 Hotline Launches in Illinois

Newsletter

Loading
No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • Ad submission
  • Contact
  • Team
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap
  • FAQ
  • Mission

© 2018 TNS - TNS theme by Frackle TNSthemes.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Politics
  • World
  • Business
  • Science
  • Entertainment
  • Gaming
  • Movie
  • Music
  • Sports
  • Health and Lifestyle
  • View Print Edition
  • Subscribe to the print newspaper
  • Contact

© 2018 TNS - TNS theme by Frackle TNSthemes.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Support independent local journalism by subscribing to the Chicago Leader print
and digital publication for just $15 a year.

Subscribe Now